Morten Hørning Jensen, «Rural Galilee and Rapid Changes: An Investigation of the Socio-Economic Dynamics and Developments in Roman Galilee», Vol. 93 (2012) 43-67
Much research on the socio-economic conditions of Galilee in the Herodian period has argued for a rapid economic deterioration amongst the rural population. This is said to have resulted in a deadly spiral of violence prompting popular protest movements of which Jesus of Nazareth became the most renowned. Other investigations, however, paint a much more lenient picture of Galilee being under only a moderate development. This article outlines the problem at hand in the research, suggests a methodology for further development and applies this to new archaeological material emerging from excavations in Galilee and the textual material available.
62 MORTEN HØRNING JENSEN
This is actually what was claimed in an article on family life in
Galilee by S. Guijarro 61. According to Guijarro, 70-75% of the
population were peasants or craftsmen living in single-room mud-
brick houses, and he uses this as an argument for his view of a period
of economic stress in Galilee. Guijarro derives these numbers from the
models of the sociologists Sjoberg and Lenski, and the idea of mud-
brick houses from an article by T. Canaan, which, in fact, describes
Arab housing in the twentieth century 62.
Guijarro’s picture is far too simplistic. At this time, we do not
have sufficient material evidence to propose such solid numbers. In
contrast, to my knowledge, every excavation in Galilee presents a
diversified picture with respect to living quarters, as demonstrated
by, for example, Y. Hirschfeld, P. Richardson and E. Meyers 63. I
take this as another indication of socio-economic stability, whereas
a poor, simple, unified mass of housing would point in the direction
of decline and debt.
7. Monetization
The issue of monetization has also been raised in the debate
surrounding the socio-economic conditions, and some have claimed
that Antipas initiated a rigid policy of minting in order to monetize
the economy more profoundly so that taxes could be collected in
coin rather than in kind 64.
However, important new data have recently been collected by the
Israeli archaeologist Danny Syon, who in his dissertation, dated 2004,
has traced coin circulation in Galilee and the Golan throughout the
61
S. GUIJARRO, “The Family in First-Century Galileeâ€, Constructing Early
Christian Families (ed. H. MOXNES) (London 1997) 42-65.
62
T. CANAAN, “The Palestinian Arab House: Its Architecture and Folk-
loreâ€, The Journal of the Palestine Oriental Society 13 (1933) 1-83.
63
Cf. Y. HIRSCHFELD, The Palestinian Dwelling in the Roman-Byzantine Pe-
riod (Studium Biblicum Franciscanum 34; Jerusalem 1995); P. RICHARDSON,
“Towards a Typology of Levantine/Palestinian Housesâ€, JSNT 27 (2004) 47-68;
E.M. MEYERS, “Roman-Period Houses From the Galilee: Domestic Architec-
ture and Gendered Spacesâ€, Symbiosis, Symbolism, and the Power of the Past
(eds. W.G. DEVER – S. GITIN) (Winona Lake, MI 2003) 193-220.
64
Cf. e. g. W.E. ARNAL, Jesus and the Village Scribes. Galilean Conflicts
and the Setting of Q (Minneapolis, MN 2000) 138.